论文标题
贝叶斯非参数调整混杂
Bayesian Nonparametric Adjustment of Confounding
论文作者
论文摘要
对观察性研究的分析越来越多地面临确定可能需要高维的可用协变量集的挑战,以满足可无知的治疗分配的假设以估计因果效应。我们提出了一种贝叶斯非参数方法,该方法同时1)根据现有的混杂选择原则优先考虑调整变量; 2)以一种允许混杂因素,暴露和结果之间复杂关系的方式估算因果影响; 3)提供因果估计,说明混杂性质的不确定性。该提案依赖于多个贝叶斯添加期回归树模型的规范,该模型与共同的先前分布相关,该分布在与感兴趣的结果相关联的基础上具有后验选择概率来协变量。一系列广泛的仿真研究表明,在各种情况下,所提出的方法相对于类似动机的方法表现良好。我们部署了研究燃煤电厂排放量对环境污染浓度的因果关系的方法,在这些方法中,由于局部和区域气象因素引起的混淆的前景引起了高维测量变量的混杂作用的不确定性。最终,我们表明,所提出的方法比替代方法在邻近年中产生更有效,更一致的结果,这是SO2排放与环境颗粒物污染之间因果关系的证据。
Analysis of observational studies increasingly confronts the challenge of determining which of a possibly high-dimensional set of available covariates are required to satisfy the assumption of ignorable treatment assignment for estimation of causal effects. We propose a Bayesian nonparametric approach that simultaneously 1) prioritizes inclusion of adjustment variables in accordance with existing principles of confounder selection; 2) estimates causal effects in a manner that permits complex relationships among confounders, exposures, and outcomes; and 3) provides causal estimates that account for uncertainty in the nature of confounding. The proposal relies on specification of multiple Bayesian Additive Regression Trees models, linked together with a common prior distribution that accrues posterior selection probability to covariates on the basis of association with both the exposure and the outcome of interest. A set of extensive simulation studies demonstrates that the proposed method performs well relative to similarly-motivated methodologies in a variety of scenarios. We deploy the method to investigate the causal effect of emissions from coal-fired power plants on ambient air pollution concentrations, where the prospect of confounding due to local and regional meteorological factors introduces uncertainty around the confounding role of a high-dimensional set of measured variables. Ultimately, we show that the proposed method produces more efficient and more consistent results across adjacent years than alternative methods, lending strength to the evidence of the causal relationship between SO2 emissions and ambient particulate pollution.